Find Near Me

10 Top-Rated Italian Restaurant in New York, Ny

Finding a trusted Italian Restaurant in New York is essential for your needs. Our 2026 directory features top-rated Italian Restaurant restaurants in New York, NY, based on verified feedback from guests. These dining spots provide professional dining and food services for the local community. Compare ratings, view hours, and find an expert near you today.

Sponsored

Local “Near Me” Tips for Italian Restaurant

Diners searching for Italian Restaurant nearby in New York, NY often check photos, menu highlights, and latest feedback before deciding where to eat.

Use sorting options, popularity scores, and cuisine tags to uncover Italian Restaurant near me that fit your preferences and budget.

Quick Links: Italian Restaurant Near Me

Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria
✨ Best Value Italian Restaurant
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (1075)

Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria

53 Great Jones St, New York

Get Directions

Find Italian Restaurant near you in New York.

Located in New York, Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria is a well-known Italian Restaurant destination. It currently holds an average rating of 4.5 based on 1075 cus…

Contact: (212) 837-2622 Call Now

More Italian Restaurant in New York

✓ Eatery ✓ market & bakery destination
Siena Pizza
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (1023)

Siena Pizza

14 Rector St, New York

Get Directions

Find Pizza Restaurant near you in New York.

Located in New York, Siena Pizza is a well-known Pizza Restaurant destination. It currently holds an average rating of 4.5 based on 1023 customer reviews. This…

Contact: (212) 406-0918 Call Now

More Pizza Restaurant in New York

✓ Petite eatery known for pizza & cannoli
Malaparte
✨ Best Value Italian Restaurant
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (1000)

Malaparte

753 Washington St, New York

Get Directions

Find Italian Restaurant near you in New York.

Located in New York, Malaparte is a well-known Italian Restaurant destination. With 1000 reviews and a 4.5 star rating, it has built strong local trust. It is …

Contact: (212) 255-2122 Call Now

More Italian Restaurant in New York

✓ Thin-crust pizza & housemade pasta
Da Claudio NYC Ristorante
✨ Best Value Italian Restaurant
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (899)

Da Claudio NYC Ristorante

21 Ann St, New York

Get Directions

Find Italian Restaurant near you in New York.

Da Claudio NYC Ristorante stands out as a trusted Italian Restaurant business serving the New York area. Customers have rated this place 4.5 stars across 899 r…

Contact: (212) 285-2668 Call Now

More Italian Restaurant in New York

✓ Italian spot for small plates & drinks
Mangia 57th - Midtown Italian Food & Corporate Catering NYC
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (881)

Mangia 57th - Midtown Italian Food & Corporate Catering NYC

57 W 57th St, New York

Get Directions

Find Lunch Restaurant near you in New York.

Mangia 57th - Midtown Italian Food & Corporate Catering NYC stands out as a trusted Lunch Restaurant business serving the New York area. It currently holds an …

Contact: (212) 582-5882 Call Now

More Lunch Restaurant in New York

✓ Mediterranean cafe with gourmet take-out
Gnocco
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (870)

Gnocco

337 E 10th St, New York

Get Directions

Find Pizza Restaurant near you in New York.

Visitors in New York often choose Gnocco for quality Pizza Restaurant services. It currently holds an average rating of 4.5 based on 870 customer reviews. This…

Contact: (212) 677-1913 Call Now

More Pizza Restaurant in New York

✓ Pizza & pasta by way of Emilia
Kimika
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (839)

Kimika

40 Kenmare St, New York

Get Directions

Find Japanese Restaurant near you in New York.

Kimika stands out as a trusted Japanese Restaurant business serving the New York area. It currently holds an average rating of 4.5 based on 839 customer review…

Contact: (212) 256-9280 Call Now

More Japanese Restaurant in New York

✓ Casual venue for Japanese-Italian fusion
L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele NYC
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (788)

L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele NYC

2 Bank St, New York

Get Directions

Find Pizza Restaurant near you in New York.

L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele NYC stands out as a trusted Pizza Restaurant business serving the New York area. Customers have rated this place 4.5 stars across …

Contact: (929) 524-6682 Call Now

More Pizza Restaurant in New York

Saint Theo's
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (782)

Saint Theo's

340 Bleecker St, New York

Get Directions

Find Pizza Restaurant near you in New York.

Saint Theo's stands out as a trusted Pizza Restaurant business serving the New York area. It currently holds an average rating of 4.5 based on 782 customer rev…

Contact: (212) 969-8221 Call Now

More Pizza Restaurant in New York

✓ Posh eatery for Italian-inspired fare
Denino's Greenwich Village
Top Rated Popular
★ 4.5 (725)

Denino's Greenwich Village

93 MacDougal St, New York

Get Directions

Find Pizza Restaurant near you in New York.

Denino's Greenwich Village is one of the most popular Pizza Restaurant locations in New York. Customers have rated this place 4.5 stars across 725 reviews. Thi…

Contact: (646) 838-6987 Call Now

More Pizza Restaurant in New York

✓ Warm Italian eatery with pizza & pasta

Other Cities for Italian Restaurant in NY

Nearby Cities for Italian Restaurant

Prev Page 7 of 22 Next

Frequently Asked Questions

? How to locate the best Italian Restaurant nearby in New York, NY?

Locate the best-rated Italian Restaurant by evaluating customer ratings and verified reviews on Find Near Me. Our directory organizes businesses based on data-driven feedback to ensure you find trusted local professionals.

? Is there any Italian Restaurant open now in New York, NY?

The majority of Italian Restaurant profiles on our site include precise opening hours. We advise checking individual business pages for current status or using the 'Call Now' feature to verify availability.

? Name the top-rated Italian Restaurant in New York, NY?

The top-rated Italian Restaurant is determined by a combination of high average ratings and a significant number of customer reviews. Explore our list to see the current leaders in New York, NY.