Bar Pizza Restaurant

New Bethel Ordinary in Wanamaker, IN

Located in Wanamaker, IN, New Bethel Ordinary provides professional Pizza Restaurant services. Known for their focus on a great experience and culinary quality, this business offers quality dining and food services. With a dedicated team of dining spots, they serve guests with care. Explore their testimonials, gallery, and contact info below.

"Join more than 2715 satisfied customers in Wanamaker who recommend New Bethel Ordinary with a solid 4.5/5 stars."

Hours Not Verified Typically: 11 AM – 10 PM 🛡️ Verified: March 16, 2026 🎯 Trust Score: 9.5/10 📍Wanamaker, IN 🏙️ ~0 miles from center 🏷️Pizza Restaurant ⭐4.5 / 5 (2715 reviews) Verified 📞(317) 862-5020 🔗Visit Website

Overview of New Bethel Ordinary

When people search for Pizza Restaurant near me in Wanamaker, IN, many choose New Bethel Ordinary as a trusted local option.

With an average rating of 4.5 stars based on 2715 verified reviews, New Bethel Ordinary has built a strong reputation among people exploring Pizza Restaurant options in Wanamaker, IN.

Why Choose New Bethel Ordinary?

✔️ Highlights & Pros

● Excellent Customer Satisfaction
● Highly Popular Local Choice
● Verified Online Presence

📝 Analysis & Notes

No significant concerns identified by our automated analysis.

About

"Data indicates 90% customer loyalty for New Bethel Ordinary, making it a top-tier choice for 2715 clients."

New Bethel Ordinary is one of the most popular Pizza Restaurant locations in Wanamaker. With 2715 reviews and a 4.5 star rating, it has built strong local trust. Address: 8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, United States. You can contact them at or visit their official website at http://www.nbopizza.net/ for more information.

For inquiries, call (317) 862-5020.

Photo

Front view of New Bethel Ordinary in Wanamaker - Verified Pizza Restaurant nearby.

Compare New Bethel Ordinary with Nearby Businesses

Business Name	Rating	Reviews	Status	Action
New Bethel Ordinary (This)	⭐ 4.5	2715	Hours Not Verified	-
Magoo's Pizza	⭐ 4.7	172	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
GOD FATHERS PIZZA EXPRESS	⭐ 4.2	46	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta	⭐ 4.5	444	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
Greek's Pizzeria & Tap Room Beech Grove	⭐ 4.3	67	Hours Not Verified	View Profile

Location

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, United States

Get Directions View on Google Maps

Key Details & Local Information

Official Category: Pizza Restaurant (Bar, Pizza Restaurant)

Full Address: 8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, United States

Offering top-tier services throughout Wanamaker, IN. Active in 46239 and surrounding neighborhoods.

Areas Served: Wanamaker, Central Wanamaker, Wanamaker Metro Area, Nearby Neighborhoods

Average Rating: ⭐ 4.5 (Based on 2715 user reviews)

Opening Hours: Not yet verified

💡 Local Insights & Tips for Wanamaker

⏰ Best Time

"Busy times for Pizza Restaurant in Wanamaker typically fall between 11 AM and 2 PM. Booking in advance is recommended."

📍 Local Info

"Locating quality Pizza Restaurant in Wanamaker requires comparing verified reviews to ensure current standards."

Nearby Places & Exploration

While visiting New Bethel Ordinary, many people also explore other nearby businesses, professional services, and local conveniences in Wanamaker, IN. The area is a prime destination for those looking for reliable Pizza Restaurant and high-quality local expertise.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!

Leave a Review

Name

Email (Private)

Rating

Your Review

Similar Places

Magoo's Pizza

★ 4.7

Indianapolis

More Pizza Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

GOD FATHERS PIZZA EXPRESS

★ 4.2

Indianapolis

More Pizza Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta

★ 4.5

Indianapolis

More Pizza Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Greek's Pizzeria & Tap Room Beech Grove

★ 4.3

Beech Grove

More Pizza Restaurant Near Me in Beech Grove

Other Services in Wanamaker

Bar

Nearby Service Areas

Marion Indianapolis East Chicago Anderson South Bend Waterloo

Manage & Contact

Full Address: 8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, United States

Phone: (317) 862-5020

Website: www.nbopizza.net

Get Directions 💼 Claim This Business

Owner? Display this badge on your site

Copy this code to your website:

<a href="https://find-nearme.com/places/new-bethel-ordinary" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
   <img src="https://find-nearme.com/badge/new-bethel-ordinary.svg"
        alt="New Bethel Ordinary - Top Rated Pizza Restaurant on Find Near Me"
        width="200"
        height="90"
        style="border:0;"
        loading="lazy">
 </a>

Frequently Asked Questions

Q What services does New Bethel Ordinary provide?

New Bethel Ordinary specializes in Pizza Restaurant and related professional services in Wanamaker. They are known for providing quality solutions to local clients.

Q What is the overall rating of New Bethel Ordinary?

New Bethel Ordinary has a verified rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars, based on 2715 customer reviews. This score reflects their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Q Where is New Bethel Ordinary located?

New Bethel Ordinary is located at 8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, United States. Detailed directions and a map are available on our listing page.

Q How can I contact New Bethel Ordinary directly?

You can reach New Bethel Ordinary by calling +13178625020. Our platform also provides links to their official website if available.

Q Does New Bethel Ordinary have verified opening hours?

While specific hours for New Bethel Ordinary are not yet verified, most Pizza Restaurant businesses in Wanamaker operate between 9 AM and 5 PM on weekdays.

Q Is New Bethel Ordinary highly recommended?

Yes, with a rating of 4.5 stars, New Bethel Ordinary is considered one of the top-rated Pizza Restaurant providers in Wanamaker. Customers frequently praise their professionalism and quality.