Fine Dining Restaurant Family Restaurant Italian Restaurant

Mama Carolla's – Top-Rated Italian Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis, IN (2662 Reviews)

Name: Mama Carolla's
Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN, 46220, US
Rating: 4.7

"Join more than 2662 satisfied customers in Indianapolis who recommend Mama Carolla's with a solid 4.7/5 stars."

Hours Not Verified Typically: 11 AM – 10 PM 🛡️ Verified: May 01, 2026 🎯 Trust Score: 9.5/10 📍Indianapolis, IN 🏙️ ~3.9 miles from center 🏷️Italian Restaurant ⭐4.7 / 5 (2662 reviews) ⭐ Top Performance (Avg. is 4.5 in Indianapolis) Verified 📞(317) 259-9412 ✓ Romantic Italian Dining Destination

Why Choose Mama Carolla's?

🏆 When people search for Italian Restaurant near me in Indianapolis, IN, many choose Mama Carolla's as a trusted local option. ⭐ It is especially known for Romantic Italian dining destination, making it a frequently visited spot for both residents and visitors. With an average rating of 4.7 stars based on 2662 verified reviews, Mama Carolla's has built a strong reputation. 📍 Find the best italian restaurant near you today!

✔️ Highlights & Pros

● Excellent Customer Satisfaction
● Highly Popular Local Choice
● Verified Online Presence

📝 Analysis & Notes

No significant concerns identified by our automated analysis.

About

"With a 4.7/5 rating, approximately 94% of customers reported a positive experience with Mama Carolla's."

Mama Carolla's is one of the most popular Italian Restaurant locations in Indianapolis. It currently holds an average rating of 4.7 based on 2662 customer reviews. Romantic Italian dining destination. Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States. You can contact them at or visit their official website at http://www.mamacarollas.com/ for more information.

For inquiries, call (317) 259-9412.

Features & Amenities

✓ Romantic Italian dining destination

Photo

Compare Mama Carolla's with Nearby Businesses

Business Name	Rating	Reviews	Status	Action
Mama Carolla's (This)	⭐ 4.7	2662	Hours Not Verified	-
Diavola	⭐ 4.5	846	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
Ambrosia	⭐ 4.7	698	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
Vicino	⭐ 4.5	343	Hours Not Verified	View Profile
Iaria's Italian Restaurant	⭐ 4.6	1723	Hours Not Verified	View Profile

Location

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States

Get Directions View on Map

💡 Local Insights & Tips for Indianapolis

⏰ Best Time

"Busy times for local services in Indianapolis usually fall between 11 AM and 2 PM. Booking ahead is recommended."

📍 Local Info

"Locating quality local services in Indianapolis is easier when checking verified reviews from the last 6 months."

Nearby Places & Exploration

While visiting Mama Carolla's, many people also explore other nearby businesses, professional services, and local conveniences in Indianapolis, IN. The area is a prime destination for those looking for reliable Italian Restaurant and high-quality local expertise.

Key Details & Local Information

Official Category: Italian Restaurant (Fine Dining Restaurant, Family Restaurant, Italian Restaurant)

Full Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States

Based in Indianapolis, this provider services the entire 46220 postal code area and greater IN region.

Areas Served: Indianapolis, Central Indianapolis, Indianapolis Metro Area, Nearby Neighborhoods

Average Rating: ⭐ 4.7 (Based on 2662 user reviews)

Opening Hours: Not yet verified

Customer Reviews

Write a Review

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!

Leave a Review

Name

Email (Private)

Rating

Your Review

Contact Information

📞

(317) 259-9412

Call Now

🔗

www.mamacarollas.com

Business Website

📍

1031 E 54th St

Indianapolis, IN 46220

Location

🔴

Hours Not Verified

Currently Closed

Similar Places

Diavola

★ 4.5

Indianapolis

More Italian Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Ambrosia

★ 4.7

Indianapolis

More Italian Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Vicino

★ 4.5

Indianapolis

More Italian Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Iaria's Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6

Indianapolis

More Italian Restaurant Near Me in Indianapolis

Southeast Family Dental

★ 5.0

Indianapolis

More Dental Clinic Near Me in Indianapolis

Other Services in Indianapolis

Restaurant Pizza Restaurant Dental Clinic American Restaurant Breakfast Restaurant

Nearby Service Areas

Marion East Chicago Anderson South Bend Waterloo Zionsville

Quick Actions

📞Call Now 🌐 www.mamacarollas.com 🗺️ Get Directions ⭐ Read Reviews ✍️ Write Review

Manage & Contact

Full Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States

Phone: (317) 259-9412

Website: www.mamacarollas.com

Email: user@domain.com

💼 Claim Business

Owner? Display this badge on your site

Copy this code to your website:

<a href="https://find-nearme.com/places/mama-carolla-s" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">
   <img src="https://find-nearme.com/badge/mama-carolla-s.svg"
        alt="Mama Carolla&#039;s - Top Rated Italian Restaurant on Find Near Me"
        width="200"
        height="90"
        style="border:0;"
        loading="lazy">
 </a>

🔍 Related "Near Me" Searches

Frequently Asked Questions About Mama Carolla's Near Me

Q What services does Mama Carolla's offer near me?

Mama Carolla's provides professional italian restaurant to customers near you. Contact them directly to learn about their specific services, availability, and how they can help with your needs.

Q Where is Mama Carolla's located?

Mama Carolla's is located at 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States. Use the map directions to find the easiest route from your location.

Q How can I contact Mama Carolla's?

You can contact Mama Carolla's by phone at +13172599412 or visit their website through our secure directory. Most businesses also respond to inquiries through their contact forms.

Q What are the business hours for Mama Carolla's?

Mama Carolla's's business hours are listed in their contact information. We recommend calling ahead to confirm their current hours and availability, as they may vary by season or special circumstances.

Q How do customers rate Mama Carolla's?

Mama Carolla's has received 2,662 customer reviews with an average rating of 4.7 stars. These ratings reflect real customer experiences and satisfaction with their italian restaurant.

Q Is Mama Carolla's currently open?

To check if Mama Carolla's is currently open, please call them directly at +13172599412. Many businesses also update their hours online, but calling ensures you get the most current information about their availability.

Additional Questions

Q What services does Mama Carolla's provide?

Mama Carolla's specializes in Italian Restaurant and related professional services in Indianapolis. They are known for providing quality solutions to local clients.

Q What is the overall rating of Mama Carolla's?

Mama Carolla's has a verified rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars, based on 2662 customer reviews. This score reflects their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Q Where is Mama Carolla's located?

Mama Carolla's is located at 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States. Detailed directions and a map are available on our listing page.

Q How can I contact Mama Carolla's directly?

+13172599412

Q Is Mama Carolla's highly recommended?

Yes, with a rating of 4.7 stars from 2662 customer reviews, Mama Carolla's is considered one of the top-rated Italian Restaurant providers in Indianapolis. Customers frequently praise their professionalism and quality service.